
Episode Description
Following news of Pope Leo XIV’s lung cancer diagnosis after undergoing surgery this week, the TCA team reflects on the Holy Father’s public witness to suffering and the powerful example he offers to cancer patients and their families around the world. They emphasize the importance of solidarity through prayer, and why Catholics should turn to St. Peregrine, the patron saint of cancer patients, to intercede for the Pope’s healing and recovery.

With artificial intelligence becoming an increasingly common parenting tool, policy analyst and mother Abby McCloskey joins to discuss her recent Bloomberg piece examining how AI may be changing motherhood for the worse. Research suggests roughly 80% of parents use AI for parenting, and a third trust its advice over their own instincts. McCloskey explores the troubling consequences of outsourcing parenting decisions to algorithms, and how the convenience of AI may come at a greater cost than parents realize.

As we celebrate Respect Life Month, Emily Berning joins us to share the inspiring work of Let Them Live, the pro-life organization she founded with her husband. She shares how what began with a $1,200 gift to help a struggling expectant mother has grown into an organization that has helped more than 1,000 women choose life.

Catch the show every Saturday at 7amET/5pmET on EWTN radio!
And don’t forget to subscribe to TCA’s daily media roundup for smart Catholic news and commentary delivered straight to your inbox.
Bios

Abby M. McCloskey is the founder and principal of McCloskey Policy LLC, a research and consulting firm serving business and political leaders, and the host of the Beyond Talking Points podcast. She served as the domestic policy director on multiple presidential campaigns, including Governor Rick Perry’s 2016 presidential campaign, and economic advisor to Governor Jeb Bush’s 2016 presidential campaign. She was the program director of economic policy at the American Enterprise Institute in Washington, D.C. and the director of research at the Financial Services Roundtable. Her work has been featured in The Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, National Affairs, Politico, The Dispatch, The Hill, Forbes, National Review and others, and she writes a weekly opinion column for Bloomberg. She has testified before the US Congress about her research on child care, paid leave, and banking regulation. She holds an M.S. in Applied Economics from Johns Hopkins University. She lives with her husband, three children, and golden retriever in Texas. In her spare time, she edits spy novels.

Emily Berning is a prominent pro-life advocate and the President and Co-Founder of Let Them Live, a national nonprofit dedicated to empowering women in crisis pregnancies to help them choose life. Under her leadership, Let Them Live has grown into a powerful movement that has saved more than 1,000 lives. Her journey into advocacy began with a personal donation to a homeless woman considering abortion, inspiring her to establish a supportive community for pregnant women in financial or personal crises. She graduated from Colorado State University with a degree in Biological Sciences. Emily has appeared on national media platforms including radio, podcasts, and YouTube. Beyond her work in the pro-life movement, she is a passionate voice on faith, culture, and conservative values, inspiring audiences with her personal journey of faith, leadership, and the fight for life. She is based in Fort Wayne, Indiana.
The following transcript is machine generated.
| Ashley | Welcome back to With consequences on W10 radio. I'm your host, Ashley Maguire. |
| Betsy | And I'm Betty Fentress. |
| Ashley | An artificial intelligence is a hot topic, one that our dear Pope Leo has even taken up, given its easy accessibility and the many dangers that come with it. And our next guest, Abby McCloskey, writes for Bloomberg and The Dallas Morning News and has written a thought provoking piece this week looking at its impact on motherhood from eroding peer to peer support networks and fostering perfectionism to adding entirely new layers of digital surveillance. McCloskey argues that AI is taking an already intense chapter of life and turning up the volume. Today, we're going to talk about what happens when algorithms try to replace intuition and how mothers can navigate the digital age without burning out, and what it will take to restore balance. That's a lot. Welcome to the show, Abby. |
| Abby McCloskey | So much. Ashley. |
| Ashley | So in your piece, you note that public concern has rightly focused on A's impacts on children. And your piece is the first thing that I've seen that really tackles its effects on mothers who, as we know, are already sort of straining and struggling in a world of information overload, tech overload. So what was it specifically that made you hone in on AI and moms? |
| Abby McCloskey | Yeah, thanks for that, Ashley. You know, I had seen the increasing research about the impact on kids. Whether it's cognitive offloading, kids, having a, I think for them. And so they do better maybe on their homework, but worse on tests. How AI is supplanting relationships for some kids, and even kids younger than five are using generative AI to all sorts of different consequences. But we also know that the majority of parents, something like 80%, use AI for parenting. And so I thought, if it's having these effects on kids who have developing brains and all sorts of differences, I get that. But it's also impacting how parents are thinking and mothers in particular. And when I started looking at the research, I think there's pretty compelling evidence that it already has started to do so. And the trend is likely upwards from here. So it happens in a number of different avenues. If we stay with the cognitive offloading piece, like what we see with kids, moms, dads are using AI to ask their parenting questions. And a third of parents report in a study out of the children's hospital cargo that they're trusting what AI says about their parenting more than their own maternal or maternal instincts. And over time, you could see how that would erode confidence and how you think is best to deal or treat your own child, which then creates more reliance on AI for parenting. So we have this cognitive offloading piece. And I think I started the article by myself prompting Gemini, how would you go about undermining motherhood? And the answer was, as you as you said, your intro turning up the dial on the optimization intensity, perfecting nature of parenting that is already happening today, especially. And I would say more so at the upper end of the income spectrum. There's different challenges for lower income moms, which you can talk about. But for moms with resources, including time and the ability to optimize everything from a grocery list to meal planning to the children's activities, AI creates another way that there's just perpetually better and better and better and better, and more and more and more ways you can be a good parent. And that can end up, not surprisingly, having inverse effects on how actually attended and present of a parent you are. And the third I know I'm going on long now, but I would say the third way is AI does introduce yet another new tech monitoring responsibility for mothers. So less changing how mothers think about the world and about parenting. But it is yet another responsibility that mothers should be taking seriously. And that falls in their laps, because we don't have a lot of public controls or guardrails for AI and kids. |
| Betsy | So you write in the piece that you actually asked AI the question of whether your son should share a bedroom. Did you do that just because you're a researcher in this lane of family and AI and motherhood? Or did you genuinely feel that you didn't really have the chops to figure all this out on your own without potentially making a terrible mistake? |
| Abby McCloskey | It's it's interesting. Betsy. Why did I do it? I have great, you know, girlfriends who are mothers with kids the same age. I have sisters, I have my own mother. And I have asked some of them, you know, the same question to as we're rearranging rooms in our house, as everyone's getting older and people's needs are shifting. I think the addictive nature of AI, I'm sure I was looking at it for some sort of academic source for an article I was writing. I was like, well, well, I'm worried about where to find the latest academic research on this. Like, what do we think about siblings sharing a bedroom in the age band and the gender? And how does that actually work? And that, I think, is the slippery nature of it because there's no need. I don't actually think there's any sort of precise answer or right or wrong about when and who shares a bedroom and why. But as long as there's someone else to ask kind of in the room at your fingertips, you don't have to call or engage in anything else. Why not? And it's interesting, Betsy, because most parents say they like using AI. Like the same surveys that say 80% of parents use it. Parents say this is this is really helpful. It's like it's easy, but everything does have a cost. And I do think over time, as it becomes easier and easier to ask these questions, get quick answers, answers that kind of stroke your ego and affirm what you already thought anyway, because that's what it's designed to do. You could see how it begins to erode maternal networks, peer to peer networks. And increasingly, a mom is making her decisions on parenting based on what some, you know, completely black box of an algorithm is saying on the other side. |
| Betsy | And how are they looking at what I was looking at the links to see what the source is? I mean, do they have any idea if the the person who is giving the response shares their values? You know, somebody might live in New York City, somebody might live in Texas where your whole space configuration is completely different. That's what I find scary, is that do people know how to discern the source? |
| Abby McCloskey | Right. And, you know, my sense of having used Chat and Gemini and others, is it they tend to be a little bit tricky about which paragraphs have sourcing to them and which don't, where the sources go. Even when you click on the underlying source, it may or may not be the most relevant or recent. And I think what concerned me, seeing that study from Children's Hospital of Chicago, that a third of parents are trusting AI over their own instincts, is that AI still hallucinates, and I know from using it for work that there are just very clear things, like how many senators in the U.S. Senate are Republican, and it will just give the wrong answer. And so when it's giving backs wrong that, you know, are not right, that's one thing. But all of a sudden, if you're using it to help medicate your child, make vaccine decisions, make school decisions, make any sort of other types of decisions where it's randomly hallucinating or just saying something without any sort of backing behind it. I think it becomes incredibly concerning. That doesn't even get into the value stuff, Betsy. That's just our things, right? Or, you know, right or wrong in an objective way. |
| Ashley | When I was reading your piece, I was thinking about, you know, I'm coming kind of coming out the other end of parenting. And, but when I was starting out, mercifully, there was no AI, but what there was, was just a mountain of books and theories about parenting. And it was like attachment parenting, gentle parenting, this kind of parenting. And I got so overwhelmed that I just sort of vowed to read no parenting books and literally go by the seat of my pants, but not really. I mean, actually, what I did was consulted people who I felt like had, you know, their product had turned out well. And I feel like that's kind of the age old model. But do you feel like we've kind of teed this up already with just creating an industry out of motherhood that I, I would argue is kind of made moms already go insane? |
| Abby McCloskey | Yeah. I mean, I think this is yet another turn of what has been happening. Like you, there were endless, I guess I was more in the social media age. My oldest is 11, my youngest is five. I have one in the middle who's eight. Like, there's endless stuff on Instagram and social media, and I've never really had time to go into all of that. And like, you have instead got parenting advice from networks of friends. But it is also becoming the case where friends, people in the neighborhood, everyone's kind of playing in this arms race of intensive parenting. So all of a sudden, even when you're looking at your peers, you might not be satisfied with how they're doing it or what they have on offer. That's especially now the case has fewer people are having kids, so there may be fewer peers for new moms to look around and see how are they doing it. All of which I do think kind of creates more of this drive to something else. And let's go and see what the screen has to say about it. But I do think it's fundamentally a lie that parenting has to be optimized, that if you control every single thing you can within your home that, you know, you're you're you're never going to be able to fully control your child or your family. And but I think that the lie right now is that you have to give it 1,000% to make sure that you set your child off on, on the right track. And I think that's exhausting. There was a 2024 Surgeon General advisory that said something like 41% of parents are too stressed, even function. And that's before AI. |
| Ashley | Yeah. |
| Abby McCloskey | You know, I think you can look at it as someone who's raised kids before a generation or two above us and say, why is everyone gotten so soft? Like it's always been hard and it's still hard and just kind of keep on going, or you can look at it and say, maybe some things have changed. And I do think that the introduction of technology and the burden on parents to monitor it, but also just the endless ability to compare and try to receive feedback from different sources that you don't actually know if they're true or not or good or bad, has created a very complex, stressful kind of infrastructure around parenting. |
| Betsy | One of the really interesting parts about your article is that you take an idea from Jonathan Height which says, just just make a I tell you what the problems are with what you're asking. And so you asked how AI might dismantle American motherhood, and the response was that it could create hyper individualized isolation and heighten perfectionism. Why? Why do you think that is? And do you see in your generation? I'm older, this kind of catastrophizing that every decision I make is, is so consequential that it's going to paralyze me. So I have to have this, like they say, hyper individualized isolation. |
| Abby McCloskey | Yes. And I think one of the other phrases that turned out later down, I mean, had a lot of ideas for how to dismantle motherhood by them. It's like an instant bullet point list of, you know, half a dozen bullet points, including just making every single decision like sleep, training your child, moving to solids, sharing a bed, everything becomes kind of this cataclysmic fork in the road of which your child is going to succeed or fail, which is insane and and all that. And yet, I do think that the economy this generation of kids are growing up into is more competitive. I think the kind of general roll the dice and your child is middle class is not what we have anymore. I think, we are in a very polarized political environment, a polarized, I would say, religious climate, like an increasing large share of Americans who don't identify with any sort of religion. And we're kind of entering this fractured economy and society anyway. And so I think there is a lot of pressure to make sure that your child can navigate it well and that it has become, as a result, more competitive and more intense. So I don't think that AI was hallucinating and it's answer about how to make motherhood harder. I think it's very much, in fact, what, what we're seeing. The interesting thing to me, because I copied the prompt from John Height, had, I think he did it to chat about how would you ruin a generation of children. It was a big article in the Free Press last year, and the nut of that was that it would just keep children distracted. I think what I've seen in John's writing since, or what it was getting to, in its own answer about how it dismantle motherhood, is it's less of a distraction, like, I'm going to be on my phone and not looking at my kids, or it's fun to prompt all these questions I'm going to keep, you know, prompting questions. And as a result, whatever dinner's later. I'm not doing homework with my child. It actually might be rewiring how we think about things and how we relate to our kids, to other mothers. That, to me, is deeply concerning. |
| Ashley | On that. You know, you mentioned it's another technology for parents to navigate. And, you know, we bought in a long time ago to the no tech thing. Our kids don't have phones. Ever had an iPad. They go to schools where it's all textbook. However, my boys are they love stats, sports stats, facts. You know, they're just fact nuts. And so for a period, I got a little loosey goosey and I would let them, with my supervision, ask chat questions about like, you know, who was the baseball player that did x, y, z. And it wasn't until actually I went to one of these, you know, salon dinners that are happening all around the country about AI, that somebody raised that question, that it, young people, you know, with the developing brains as we know that it's actually like wiring their perception of what is a normal interaction. So can you talk a little bit about this? Because this is something Pope Leo has addressed in his encyclical. He's spoken out about kids who have basically gotten into situations where they thought they were having, that it was their friend or a relationship or something. And how, you know, I think we're we're prone to this as adults. But it had never occurred to me that, and I was embarrassed that it had not occurred to me that, children, especially teens, are susceptible to this, rewiring of what is a normal interaction. |
| Abby McCloskey | Yeah. I think you raise that. There's a great. New book out by Doctor Dana Suskind who called Human Raised, and she gets into some of this, but basically, adults do it too. Sometimes I talk on behalf of my dog. I give my dog more of a human personality than Lilly actually has. Kids do this like crazy with stuffed animals, dolls, imaginary friends. They're very quick to assign human traits to inanimate things, and what the literature is increasingly showing about AI in children is that even in infants, their brains light up in response to AI robots in the same way they would to a parent. And that's very different from watching TV to obviously looking at a book to even watching short YouTube videos, which I wouldn't recommend for your child either, but that there's something about the interaction with AI that opens what Doctor Susskind calls this the social gate, and you actually begin interacting with it as if it's another person. And that's especially the case for children. The problem is this is not just AI is not created to be your average semi annoying and disinterested person like AI is created to be an ego stroking, quick to respond, friction free, basically the way no person actually is or maybe even should be. As a result, you start imagining as a child this is what a normal human interaction is. When I ask whatever, Alexa something or Siri something, I get this quick response with a what a great question. You know, this is a when I ask my mom, she's whatever busy doing other things and she doesn't want to talk to me. And so maybe I should just be asking my questions to this machine. Maybe when my friends or my teacher doesn't say, I'm asking an awesome question, you know, maybe they actually don't like me and I should keep my questions for this. So I do think we have no idea. I mean, we are so early in the beginning of how AI will impact kids and mothers. We have 20 years now of literature showing how social media has. But this is a whole different type of technology because instead of connecting people with people, especially for kids, it's a substituting what is actually not a person. But the belief that is with this robot and this is a totally new level of technology that's particularly, I think, concerning for kids. And actually, just on your point of being in kind of a tech free household, which I applaud, I it is so beyond reach for so many families. I think it's something like 81% of kindergartners and public schools have an iPad. And there are. And it's what's frustrating to me, those iPads come loaded with cool educational apps. They also come loaded with Chrome, you know, and thus AI. And it's so sad to me that there just aren't gatekeepers, aside from the doors of your own home, for accessing these types of technologies. And in fact, in our case, because our kids were in public school initially, it was forced into our home and it was something we had set out to not have or be part of. And that's a reality, I think, for so many households. There's so many parents consistently underestimate how much their kids use screens, how much they use AI. There's kind of a lot of blissful ignorance. But on the other hand, like this, technology has been forced into the hands of so many kids, and there are so many situations where it's really hard to opt out of. And so to me, the question is kind of, what do we do now? Like, is it up to each mom on their own to manage all the pings and beeps and alerts and the the school iPads and the kids phones and the Google search history and locked down their own computers and go to the smart TVs and check the YouTube history and kind of do that nonstop day after day after day, or are there going to be better public guardrails? And to me, I think they're absolutely have to be better public guardrails and all sorts of tech, which you can talk about, but including on AI. |
| Betsy | So you mentioned doctor Suskind, and I'm glad you did, because I had flagged a piece, a sentence in your work that says, she warns that maternal instinct has been honed over millennia. These are your words and remains a core part of child rearing. While generative AI is new and often still hallucinates. And you talked about that. But why are people so quick to discard? I mean, nobody has every maternal instinct about what to do, but I, I did not grow up with any of this, and I did not rear my children with any of this. So I'm one generation ahead, but I just can't imagine not having my mom and my trusted sisters and girlfriends as people to go to for the the first line before a computer. |
| Abby McCloskey | Yeah, well, I. Think it's. In some ways it's actually a more complicated question that it appears there's a lot of different threads to it. One ties into an earlier part of the conversation we had that things do, just whether it's AI saying it's more high stakes or whether things actually have become more competitive or high stakes, maybe getting the answer a little bit more right matters more than it used to. Another, when I'm talking to my own mom is she does have no frame of reference for what it's like to raise kids with tech these days, and so that some of those conversations become less helpful than they might have in the past, where there was a more analogous generation to generation. Kind of what what are the struggles of a kid going through puberty or high school, or getting out of the infant sleep training, or whichever period of child rearing you're in? So there's been such a cataclysmic shift in the environment of raising kids. That and of itself also kind of erodes some of this maternal peer to peer network. There would be, you know, I when I read the book by Dana and saw the underlying research by, you know, the Children's Hospital in Chicago and others. Of course, there's also kind of conflicting research that, well, you know, a third of moms don't seem to have maternal instincts. They don't feel a big attachment to their child when they're born. Maybe they are isolated, don't have good friends like this, could provide a net benefit. And of course, there's all those types of things have to be considered too. But I do think, on balance, the point that Doctor Suskind was making in the book holds that, by and large, the AI systems are trained on generalities. They sometimes hallucinate. It's taking actually, who even really knows what it's pulling from, but it's flowing a lot of different things. And only a mother, a father, her child have unique insight into what that specific person needs and a deep love behind it, where this is just not like an objective spreadsheet that gets put out, but actually the type of values relationship you want to have with your child. So I, I don't doubt that there's benefits for certain mothers getting better information than they might have on their own or have access to, but I think it does still come at a cost. And I think we should be very wary about kind of offloading our thinking to do a robot. |
| Ashley | Just to play devil's advocate for a minute. I mean, you talked about like, people farming off their vaccine decisions. There still seem to be a little bit of, like, a crisis of trust in science. There's a lot of, like, conspiratorial thinking sweeping around, and I'm sorry to say it, but sometimes I think, you know, women may be a little bit prone to some of this stuff. And, there's all these, you know, niche, I don't know, things out there on the internet. So, you know, let's say I actually did this recently because I had to get a young child vaccinated. And I know that things have changed. The recommendations have about some have been taken off x, y, z. So I actually went and asked and it chat actually gave me what I thought was a very scientific pro vaccine. Like there's, you know, it showed me the harms it showed me or the potential risks and weighted against. And so is there. I mean, is there maybe a benefit for moms who are sort of drowning in this for text of disinformation, the chat can help kind of clear some of the, I don't know, misinformation. |
| Abby McCloskey | Certainly think that there can be a benefit. I've used it to my own benefit many times. I nevertheless think that. What did Pope Leo say? It's neither negative nor neutral. I think there is a cost, a hidden cost in the ease, along with potentially, by the way, like misinformation. I'm glad you got a good answer. Actually, I don't think it always like, pumps out great answers. I think it depends on the user, but that there is there's a cost to to it also. And in some ways that was the heart behind this. Behind my piece for Bloomberg Opinion was look we have majority of parents are using it. Majority of parents like it already. Parents are kind of worried about their kids exposure to it, but consistently underestimate what their kids exposure actually is. They actually should be more concerned because we're seeing how it's changing kids relationships and how they think, well, what if actually the moms and dads using the same platform are also changing how they're thinking? Somehow in the midst of this, we're like rewiring not only just childhood, but motherhood. And now with this kind of third being in the equation, that being AI, I think it has become more attractive, as you pointed out, because there's a there is an incredible amount of conspiracy and there's a loss of trust and institutions, all types of institutions. And eventually if you can't trust all types of institutions, you're going to stop trusting yourself too, because you don't know what to believe anymore, because you don't know who to trust. The surprising thing to me in all of this is that what comes out on the other side of what to trust and who to believe is indeed, perhaps like the most, the least accountable, most black box of all, which is AI, where at least if the politicians are lying to you, maybe they lose their jobs. If the news organizations are lying to you, there's other news organizations that are binding the truth. The least accountable thing is probably what AI puts out in its own private conversations with you, which are not fact checked by anyone other than the person sitting across from the screen. But it is a a dangerous place for society to be when it doesn't have trust in institutions and thus other people, and thus one's own self. And I tend to be in the camp that the way to restore said trust, especially oneself, is not going to be increasingly cognitively offloading to a machine that seems like it's going to make it worse over time and not better. |
| Ashley | Well, this is a topic that we could keep talking about for hours and hours. It's something we're all grappling with in lifetime. So we appreciate your insights, especially for mothers, many of whom our listeners are. Abby, where can our listeners find your work and follow you? |
| Abby McCloskey | Yeah, so I have a Substack McCloskey policy, and then I write weekly for Bloomberg Opinion, so you can find me in both places. |
| Ashley | Wonderful. Well, Abby, thank you so much for joining us today. |
| Abby McCloskey | Thanks so much, Ashley and Betsy. |
| Ashley | Welcome back to conversations with consequences. I'm here with my colleague Betsy Fentress, and today we are discussing something together that I know weighs heavy on the hearts of all Catholics, which was the first rather startling news that polio the 14th announced himself in an audience that he was going to undergo surgery to remove a nodule from his lung, which I think we all knew. You know, finding out that there's a nodule on your lung is never good. And then while mercifully, the operation went well, the announcement then came out that polio does have lung cancer. So, Betsy, what was your reaction upon hearing this surprising news? |
| Betsy | Well, I was really heartbroken, but I kind of immediately switched to the fact of the number of people across the world who have cancer and what that means for them in terms of solidarity, of suffering. And I also think watching the Pope gracefully go through cancer treatments, and I think it can be a really strengthening thing for people all over the world. His in France, which actually wrote about recently in Substack and the throngs of crowds, 800,000 people on the shores of lies and 150,000 people at Lord's, and 80,000 youth who showed up for a prayer vigil. He has such a capacity to show people how to approach suffering with with dignity. |
| Ashley | You know, that's such an interesting point, the juxtaposition. It's almost like in the Bible, the, you know, the entrance into Jerusalem and then the hard pivot to cavalry. And it's like, you know, the Pope, he is thicker of Christ. He he is, you know, our image of Christ on earth. And he leads the church, but he's also a man. And he just I was so moved when he went into the hospital and how the everybody was lined up for him in the hospital staff, they must feel so proud to be caretakers for the Pope. But he just had such a a serene look on his face. And he's just I think it's especially sad because, well, he's he's so new to the office, but we've all just kind of come to really love him and get to know him and especially for his, I don't know, his kind of holy serenity that he has. And so I still agree that I hadn't thought of that, that all the people suffering with cancer can now, you know, look to him. They can offer their prayers for him and they can know that this, you know, man who's the vicar of Christ is right there suffering with him. And what is more vicar of Christ than that, right? |
| Betsy | Well, you know, when you think about it, actually, three of the last four popes have very publicly shown their fragility. John Paul II had Parkinson's, and Pope Francis had all kinds of issues. Meaning at the end of his pontificate he was in a wheelchair. So I think that it really speaks to the idea that that life can be a veil of tears, and that suffering is something that is not to just be tucked away. It's meant to be lived. And and in some sense, it's kind of embraced when you don't have a choice. And it's it's a really big pro-life message, especially in the age of this growing acceptance of assisted suicide, that that being old, getting old is hard and there will be trials and tribulations. But as a person that's somewhat near age, I. I really love the idea that he is sharing his travails with the world. |
| Ashley | Yeah, I remember thinking that about Pope Francis's very public decline that he didn't try to hide. You know, I wasn't actually my first real I'm a convert. My first real encounter with the Catholic Church was watching the throngs waiting for Pope John Paul II, you know, holding vigil, basically as he was in his final hours. And my parents had the TV on 24 over seven. And I remember thinking, who is this man that all of these people are standing around basically, you know, waiting for him to pass. But they were like singing. It was so unique. But it's true. I mean, the the Holy Fathers continue to give witness to, you know, the dignity in the end of life. I mean, they give verbally witness to the dignity of from conception but until natural death. So but I think it's so important that we as Catholics pray for the Pope. I mean, we're always called to pray for the Pope, but especially now more than ever. And I was thinking how, children, this is something we should enlist children in. Because, God, you know, we know he he hears the prayers of children. And how I was very happy to hear that at my, my younger two children schools, parish school, that they immediately, on hearing the news, did a school rosary. I think they kind of broke it up into periods or like each period would start with a decade for the Pope. And, you know, I think that there is novenas that the, the prayerful or the delay faithful can be praying. I mean, they can invoke really any, any saint. But I know at the end of our conversation here will specifically pray one to Saint Peregrine. But I don't know what what thoughts do you have about how people can be praying for the Pope? |
| Betsy | Well, I just think, again, it's an issue of solidarity. And I love the fact that when something happens in the Catholic Church, we pretty much have a saint for it. So on social media, Saint Peregrine is showing up every so many, you know, scrolls. Yeah. And, I just think it's a chance to understand that life is really not frictionless and that it's it's really hard to accept news like this. And it's usually private. People are very private about their medical history. I mean, I think I saw that, you know, sometimes, like, look at Franklin Roosevelt. We didn't even know that he was paralyzed from the waist down because the media wouldn't photograph it. This is a pope that's willing to lay it all out. This is what I'm going through. I will pray for you. You will pray for me. We're really. What more can you ask for? |
| Ashley | Well, and to your point about Saint Peregrine showing up on social media and the fact that there's so many people suffering with cancer, I mean, how many more people will discover this saint and potentially pray for their intercession, even people who aren't Catholic? |
| Betsy | Exactly. |
| Ashley | Well, on that note, let's conclude with this prayer to Saint Peregrine for Pope Leo the 14th, and we invite all our listeners to pray this prayer with us and and to consider praying it regularly, or offer a decade of your rosary, or just put it as a, you know, reminder in your calendar once a day to pray for the Pope. Okay, in the name of the father and the son and the Holy Spirit. Amen. Lord Jesus, with loving hearts we lift up our Holy Father, Pope Leo the 14th, to you. Place your healing hands upon him, restore his strength, ease his discomfort, and grant him a peaceful and complete recovery. O Saint Peregrine, faithful servant of God and patron saint of cancer patients, please intercede for our Holy Father before our Lord Jesus Christ. Aid in this way by your powerful intercession. May he be blessed with healing, strength, and peace. Guide his caregivers and doctors and surround him with loving protection. Saint Peregrine, pray for 14. Amen. In the name of the father, son, and Holy Spirit. Amen. |
| Betsy | Exactly. It's a great way to end our discussion about our beloved Pope. |
| Ashley | Welcome to conversations with consequences here on EWTN radio. I'm your host, Ashley McGuire. |
| Betsy | And I'm Betty Fentress. |
| Ashley | And today we have Emily burning with us. Today, as we celebrate Respect Life Month, Emily and her husband are behind the wonderful pro-life organization Let Them Live. Founded in 2019 because they wanted to help women choose life, who felt financially strained at the thought of raising a child, they now have saved over 1000 lives. That's incredible. Thank you for joining the show today, Emily. |
| Emily Berning | Yeah, thank you for having me. I love getting to share about our mission and all the wonderful things that God is doing through us. |
| Abby McCloskey | Well. |
| Ashley | So can you tell us the story that you and your husband, Nathan, experienced in 2019 that led to the founding of this organization? |
| Emily Berning | Absolutely. Yeah. So it actually happened just before 2019. It was December 2018. I remember we were just married for a couple of months. So we really were just trying to get started with our lives. We didn't have a lot of money in our bank account at the time, but he was up late one night on Facebook in a pro-life group and saw a post from a woman saying, hey, my cousin has an abortion scheduled for Monday. Can anyone give me some advice? How do I help her? You know, she's really not living her best life and things just aren't going well. Nathan went ahead and decided to reach out to her directly and ask her. Hey, what exactly is it that is causing your cousin to think that she needs to have an abortion and to schedule this abortion? And she replied saying that she, her cousin, was evicted living in her car because she she couldn't pay her rent. She had lost her children. She lost her job. The father of the baby had abandoned her. And it was really just completely unfortunate. And all of this while again, it was December. She was in Canada, so it was absolutely freezing. And I remember it was like I said, 3:00 in the morning. He went ahead and nudged me awake and he said, hey Emily, do you want to save a life from abortion? And as someone who was so pro-life and is so pro-life, the answer is, of course I do. But like many of us, we wonder how we can actually practically do that. So I said, yeah, of course, but how do we do that? He said, look, I've got this. Mom and I talked to her and she needs about $1,200 to get back into her apartment, and she feels like that's going to help her to choose life. And we have about $1,200 in our bank account. Emily and I said, okay, let's do it. Let's give her all the money that we have. So that's exactly what we did. It was kind of crazy at the time, but I think God used that moment to obviously build something so much greater. So we gave this mom all of the money we had. We got her back into her apartment and she canceled her abortion, chose life, and sent us an ultrasound from a pregnancy center we referred her to. And that is the first mom, the first moment that gave us this, this moment of, okay, there's probably other women who are experiencing something very similar, who are having troubles with finances and are feeling like abortion is their only option. And truly, that's that's what we found. So we started going on to social media. We started posting. We started sharing stories of women who are reaching out to us looking for help. And slowly, you know, one donor started to give and then five donors. And then we started helping more moms and we started growing and it's snowballed. Here we are eight years later. And like you said, we've helped. We've helped over 1000 women choose life, and we've raised tens of millions of dollars from just very generous people. So it's really amazing to see what the Lord has done and the absolute miracle of taking just $1,200 into kind of ragtag people and turning it into something so transformational for for women and their families and our culture. |
| Betsy | So in your work with women who have these crisis pregnancies, what do you find that the financial component is the biggest hurdle that they need to overcome? Because sometimes it's only in college. Maybe I'm even in high school. My boyfriend has abandoned me. Can you go through the reasons that people say, I just don't think I can bring my pregnancy to term and talk about which of these factors you think looms the largest? |
| Emily Berning | Absolutely. I think a really big portion of them is financial, but not usually the financial problems that women experience that caused them to consider abortion or schedule an abortion. Our company by other problems. So a good example, like you said, this is something we sadly see all the time is I've been abandoned by my boyfriend or my husband. The father of this baby wants nothing to do with me or this baby. Maybe they were her financial support. Maybe he's scared because he can't pay the bills, and that's why he's pressuring her into having an abortion. Because how can they have another mouths to feed? So I would say most times it can boil down to financial support. However, there are absolutely times where there's so much else happening in her life. It could be college, it could be high school. It could be that she just doesn't have her family support. There are women that we've helped who have been victims of domestic violence and sexual assault and things like that. And so where we can really help is obviously we come alongside emotionally and we support them, but we also connect them with other resources to make sure that they have the best of the best. And then what we can really help with, for example, with a woman who might be in a domestic violence situation, is not only getting her protection, but then using our resources and our financial, you know, ability to relocate her to a safe location, because that's one of the reasons women feel pressured into abortion with domestic violence. They don't have the money to get away, to get into a safe place, and they don't want to bring a baby into a world where they they have an abuser. So those are a lot of times it does boil down to us giving financial support, but we have become more holistic in addressing so many other intersecting needs. |
| Ashley | On the financial question, the story that you told, which is absolutely incredible, by the way, that mom's needs were very acute, you know, like need this much money to get a roof over my head. But, you know, Betsy has six kids, I have five, and we're both a very aware of the fact that, you know, kids are a lot. I hate when people put price tags on kids. That's just so you know, this is what it cost to raise. But the reality is, you know, it's it's a it's a long financial haul. What what percent of the moms that you encounter are dealing with these like, acute needs or are thinking like, I can't, you know, I can barely get a roof over my head, let alone how am I going to put a kid through school feed, you know, all these things. And how do you help those moms? |
| Emily Berning | Absolutely. It really depends on the mom. Many of them are feeling just broadly overwhelmed with their situation. Some of them can point out specific things, and that's kind of the point of our whole process. So when a mom reaches out to us, we actually have a triage team. So similar to the emergency room. When you go in and the nurses assess you and they determine, you know, what your what your illness is and how quickly they need to treat you and what their treatment plan is. That's that's very similar to what we do. So when women reach out to us, we determine their abortion likelihood and kind of where they're at. We also talk to them about their financial needs. So when we are offering financial support to a mom, we sit down and we kind of dig into the nitty gritty with her. So if she does reach out to us and says, hey, I'm just struggling with a lot of things and I'm overwhelmed and it's pretty broad. We work with her to say, all right, what are the specifics here? We kind of pass, you know, we need to get into, like I said, the nitty gritty of it so that we can really start to address her problems. And so we help her to identify specifically what is overwhelming her so much that she felt the need to, you know, order abortion pills or schedule that abortion appointment. And so with that, we then come up with a financial plan. We kind of come up with a path forward with this mom that says, all right, you know, here's here's the needs we've identified, here's this financial plan that we put together. What do you think? You know, we're going to be able to help you with? Looks like you need help with six months of rent and, you know, four months of utilities and three months of your car payment, and then a mom, she'll sign off on it. And then that's that's her plan. And she knows exactly what we're helping her with, for how long we're helping her and what her responsibilities are as well. So we have, you know, certain things. To be part of our program, you do need to get a job. If you don't have one, we'll help you do that. You need to get connected with your pregnancy center will help you to do that. So we just want to make sure that she is completely insulated with the best resources possible. So sometimes, like I said, they come in and they're very broad and they just feel completely overwhelmed by everything. And that's understandable because a lot of us feel the same way as well. And we try to work out specifically what it is that is pushing her to feel like abortion is is the best option for her. |
| Betsy | Emily, a lot of people, I think, unjustly accuse organizations like yours are saying, oh, they they only care about the baby. They don't really care about the long term health of the mother and the child. So you're kind of doing an intervention at this crucial point where they're considering an abortion. Can you tell us how you partner with other organizations that once the baby is born, there's more stability provided? So that worry of like actually said, oh my gosh, how am I going to do this? I mean, diapers are expensive. Yeah, childcare is expensive. Yeah. How does that work? |
| Emily Berning | Yeah. Well, first off with Let Them Live, we do walk with these moms, for so long after they've given birth. I actually still talked to many of the moms I originally counseled years ago whose kids are turning seven years old, already, which is crazy to think about. And I've personally come alongside them and helped them. And as the organization has grown, we've also implemented more resources. So when a mom gives birth, we've partnered with wonderfully generous organizations. Every Life Diapers is a great organization that gives us free diapers. We put in these beautiful go bags that we have for our moms to take to the hospital, and it's packed full with everything that she needs, not just for the baby, with diapers and things like that, but things for herself as well. Because childbirth can be can be a little hard on your body. So we want to make sure that she's taking care of. We make sure that she's looped in with embrace Grace groups with her local pregnancy center, her local church, literally any resources that we can pull in for her to make it so that she has a community surrounding her during and after and for many years after her birth is is really important to us. I actually, just earlier this year was in San Antonio for a conference, and I met up with one of the moms that I originally helped. Her son is six years old, and we brought her dinner and we just gathered and we had community, and it was really amazing. And so that that relationship really never ends. And for me personally, you know, if someone says, well, you only care about the baby, I really push back on that because my love really is for women. I actually wanted to be an ob gyn at one point. I love women so much. I think women are beautifully and wonderfully made, and God made women just just so uniquely to bring life. And that's really our focus is, is meeting her needs where she's at and figuring out what she needs to feel like she can choose life. |
| Ashley | You mentioned abortion pills, and there's no question that that's the direction the abortion industry is shifting. It's now I think two thirds of all abortions are through pills. And I was thinking about that when, again, your your initial story. This was, you know, a woman had an appointment and there was kind of like, okay, you got an appointment. That's something you tell people about, you put on your calendar. But the abortion pills, it's so kind of a morphs. It's so much easier, sadly, to make it an even more private thing that people don't know about. They don't you don't need somebody to drive you. So how has that changed what you're doing and how you're able to encounter women and meet them in these crucial moments? |
| Emily Berning | Yeah. You bring up such a good point. The abortion pill really threw us for a loop, especially with the prevalence of it, because like you said, women can order these online. There's not hey, I have an appointment in one week. It's I got these shipped overnight and I can take them in the privacy of my own home. And really, that has caused us to have to work so much quicker. That has caused us to have to be able to, yeah, work quicker, work smarter with with the women and say, you know, be able to to give support to them a lot faster. Unfortunately, we're seeing the whole pro-life movement struggle with with the abortion pills because they're so unregulated. They're they're so dangerous. They're so private. And so really our reach is we have a huge social media presence. And that's what I encourage a lot of social media or pro-life organizations, rather to to do is to be on social media, because that is also where women are in the privacy of their own homes. They're scrolling social media, they're looking at videos. Many times we have popped up on the phones of women who are about to take that abortion pill, and they see something from let them live or they Google something and let them live pops up and they give us a call, and then we have to work quickly. And that moment because there's literally seconds probably between them taking the first pill. I also think it's very important that people know about abortion pill reversal. We've had a number of success stories that let them live with abortion pill reversal. Unfortunately, you know, there are times where a woman does take the first set of pills and, didn't really know her options before she did that. So we always make sure we have that on hand as well. But it's also very important that we just share information. And this is why I love organizations like Live Action, you know, students for life, so many different pro-life organizations that are exposing the abortion pill for what? For what it is and and for what it does to women in the harm it does to women. So we're really on a time crunch. The abortion pill has, has really, has caused us to adjust the way we do things and the efficiency and the, the speed at which we, you know, reach women and, and help them. |
| Betsy | So when you're like when your, you know, ad pops up, what is the first thing that a woman who is contemplating an abortion can do? Can they DM you? Can they text you? What is that normal first line of contact? |
| Emily Berning | Yeah, they can DM us. They can text our hotline. They can call our hotline. They can go on our website and submit a form. They can send an email. We've made it possible for them to reach out to us in any way that they want. And we have people ready to respond immediately, which is which is huge. I think it's very important that the pro-life movement is very responsive and let them live, really is. |
| Betsy | You know, I'm looking at you on zoom and you have this beautiful class of photos of babies behind you. Which leads me to ask, what role does ultrasound play in getting women to understand what is actually growing inside of them? |
| Emily Berning | Oh, ultrasound is so, so important. Just the other day I was showing my nephew a picture of his own ultrasound and I showed it to him and he said was that was me as a baby. And I said, yes, it's that human beings recognize a baby when we see it, right? The baby may still be growing, the baby may still be developing, but it establishes that that motherly, instinctual, natural motherly connection that women have been just just created with for their babies. So when a woman sees her child on ultrasound or hears the heartbeat, it's no longer the information that was peddled to them that this is just a clump of cells. It's no longer this inanimate being that has no emotion or life to it. And I think that's really important. And I think that's why we see so many women choose life after seeing ultrasound. And that's why at Let Them Live, it's so important for us to make sure women, if they haven't come to us through a pregnancy center referral, that we refer them to a pregnancy center for an ultrasound so that they can connect with their baby. That's such a big part that's missing. With so many women who are considering abortion. They just feel that disconnect. So ultrasound, what a powerful tool. And it's getting even better. You've got the 3D ultrasounds, which are absolutely amazing. You can see all the little features and you see that child and you're like, okay, wait, they look like a human being. They don't look like an alien. You know, they look like I, you know, and we start to see and remember that we also were that age once. We also were in the womb. Once every person who was walking this earth had to have at least at one point been in the womb at that stage. And so it it's a really beautiful thing. And I thank God for technology. Truly. |
| Ashley | There's so much debate about what public opinion is, where it's at, especially with younger generations. But but you're really on the front lines. Do you see a shift in attitudes and thoughts about sort of the morality of this issue? Because I know a lot of women, they may feel like they're doing something wrong, but they do it anyways, again out of desperation. |
| Emily Berning | I do, I think I see a lot of younger people because they have so much access to information just at their fingertips. I do believe that the younger generation is starting to wake up to, you know, this, this crazy culture of, oh, well, abortion is normal abortion, health care, that type of rhetoric and say, actually, no, it's not. There's really no excuse not to be pro-life in 2026 because we have every single piece of information available at our fingertips. So I hope so. I hope that we can continue promoting this culture of life. Let Them Live actually has pro-choice donors. It's kind of a very odd thing, but I absolutely love it. There are people out there that I guess, you know, want to help women, you know, make a choice. And my hope is that when they see these babies and they see these moms and they see their transformation, that they become pro-life, because that's really the only way to I think that's the only way to to be so. |
| Ashley | Well, we thank you so much for this incredible work that you're doing. How inspiring. Where can our listeners find out more? Where can they donate? Where where can they find you on social media? All the things. |
| Emily Berning | Yeah, let them live. Dot org is our website. You can just type and let them live. Same thing with social media. If you type in let them live, you'll see us pop up. And I would say go ahead and follow us. There's just really wonderful testimonies of our moms. Very cute pictures of babies. We all love babies very much, and just lots of opportunities to get involved and be on the front lines and live out your pro-life convictions. |
| Ashley | Wonderful. Emily, thank you so much for joining us today. |
| Emily Berning | Thank you for having me. |

